Canada's asylum acceptance rate has soared to 82% in 2024, up from 64% in 2018, with more than 95% of claims from Iran and Turkey being approved. This is not just about "helping refugees"—it signals a deeply broken system that prioritizes speed over scrutiny.
1. The Surge in Asylum Approvals is Not a Coincidence
- Increased approvals (37,000 in 2023 vs. 14,000 in 2018) do not reflect a worsening global refugee crisis.
- Instead, this coincides with looser screening, political decisions, and an overwhelmed system.
- Why are certain countries given near-automatic approvals (Iran, Turkey) while others face more scrutiny?
This is not about protecting the most vulnerable. It’s about cutting corners.
2. The "Paper Review" System is a Recipe for Fraud
- In a real asylum system, every case should be thoroughly examined.
- But now, Canada allows some claims to be approved without a hearing, meaning minimal scrutiny for applicants from "pre-approved" countries.
- Paper reviews have only two outcomes:
- Acceptance
- A referral for a hearing (but never an outright rejection)
This means zero risk of immediate denial, encouraging bogus claims from those who know the system is rigged in their favour.
3. Backlog Manipulation: "Processing Faster" at What Cost?
- A backlog of 250,000 cases is being used as an excuse to approve claims without full hearings.
- Instead of fixing the backlog by prioritizing genuine refugees, Canada has streamlined approvals, creating a rubber-stamp asylum system.
- This is a policy choice, not a necessity.
4. Iran and Turkey: Why the 95% Acceptance Rate?
- Are people fleeing persecution? Yes, some.
- Are 95% of applicants genuine refugees? Highly doubtful.
- Turkey and Iran are authoritarian states, but why the blanket acceptance policy?
- These high approval rates create incentives for economic migrants to exploit the system.
5. A System Ripe for Abuse
- Fewer hearings = More fraud.
- Higher approval rates = More bogus claims.
- The result? Real refugees get lost in the flood of fraudulent claims.
Instead of creating a fair and rigorous system, Canada has opened the floodgates to abuse, prioritizing speed over legitimacy.
Final Verdict: Canada is Rewarding Fraud, Not Refugees
Canada’s asylum system is broken because it values political optics over genuine humanitarianism.
- Approving claims without hearings weakens credibility.
- Handing out near-automatic approvals to specific countries invites manipulation.
- Real refugees suffer while fraudulent claims clog the system.
A real solution? Restore rigorous screening, enforce balanced acceptance rates, and prioritize those facing genuine persecution—not just those from politically favoured nations.
Time to fix the system before Canada becomes a global magnet for asylum fraud.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thanks for your thoughts, comments and opinions, will be in touch. Peter Clarke